Former All Blacks Rally Behind Samipeni Finau Amid Controversial Tackle Criticism

Former All Blacks players have stepped forward in support of Chiefs’ blindside flanker Samipeni Finau following scrutiny over his recent tackle on Tane Edmed, with some labeling the debate around it as “ridiculous.”

The incident in question occurred during a clash between the Chiefs and the Waratahs, where Finau’s robust tackle on Edmed sparked discussions regarding the legality and timing of the hit.

Finau’s tackling style has drawn attention throughout the season, especially after a similar late hit on Reds flyhalf Tom Lynagh earlier in the year. These incidents have earned Finau a reputation as a physical and uncompromising player on the field.

Former All Black Sir John Kirwan expressed his frustration over the discussions around Finau’s tackle, dismissing criticisms as unwarranted. “It’s ridiculous that we’re talking about it, and it’s ridiculous that someone across the Tasman is moaning about it,” Kirwan stated on The Breakdown on Sky Sport NZ.

Kirwan highlighted Finau’s physical presence as reminiscent of legendary All Black Jerome Kaino, suggesting that such players should be celebrated for their aggressive playing style.

Ex-All Black Jeff Wilson acknowledged the risks associated with Finau’s style of play but defended the legality of his recent tackles. “He’s running a risk if he gets it slightly wrong and he has to live with those consequences,” Wilson commented.

Wilson emphasized that while Finau’s approach may be aggressive, it falls within the boundaries of legal play. He also questioned whether similar scrutiny would be applied if the situation involved a player from another rugby nation.

The discussions reflect broader debates within rugby regarding player safety, fair play, and the interpretation of physicality on the field. Finau’s style, characterized by robust tackling and strong defensive presence, has become a focal point in these ongoing conversations.

As rugby continues to evolve, discussions around player conduct and tackling techniques remain essential aspects of the game, with former players like Kirwan and Wilson offering valuable insights into the nuances of physical play at the elite level.