Are there trick weapons in Elden Ring?

Elden Ring, the latest epic from FromSoftware, has captivated the gaming world with its sprawling open world, challenging encounters, and unique brand of lore and atmosphere. However, one notable absence has sparked discussion among fans: the lack of “trick weapons,” a signature feature of the developer’s previous title, Bloodborne.

Bloodborne’s trick weapons were more than just armaments; they were extensions of the player’s character, transforming seamlessly between elegant swords and brutal cleavers, offering a diverse and dynamic combat experience. The absence of these transformative weapons in Elden Ring begs the question: was this a conscious design decision, and if so, what are the implications for the overall gameplay experience?

There are several arguments to support the deliberate omission of trick weapons. Firstly, Elden Ring’s weapon variety is vast, boasting over 300 unique armaments compared to Bloodborne’s more focused arsenal. This sheer number encourages experimentation and allows players to tailor their playstyle to specific encounters. Introducing trick weapons amidst such a diverse pool could potentially overshadow other weapon options and dilute the focus on strategic weapon selection.

Secondly, the inclusion of Ashes of War in Elden Ring provides a different type of weapon customization. These equippable skills alter a weapon’s moveset and add elemental effects, offering a degree of tactical flexibility similar to the transformations seen in trick weapons. While not as transformative, Ashes of War allow for a broader range of existing weapons to be adapted to specific needs.

Finally, the thematic and mechanical differences between Elden Ring and Bloodborne are noteworthy. Bloodborne’s gothic setting and aggressive, fast-paced combat were perfectly complemented by the transformative and brutal nature of trick weapons. Elden Ring, with its expansive landscapes and emphasis on exploration and diverse combat styles, might not have required the same level of weapon dynamism. The slower, more deliberate combat allows for a greater focus on positioning and strategic use of different weapon types, potentially offering a different kind of combat depth compared to the frenetic action of Bloodborne.

However, the absence of trick weapons doesn’t necessarily signify a lack of innovation in Elden Ring’s combat system. The dual-wielding mechanic and the mounted combat elements, while not transformative, add new layers of complexity and tactical options to the player’s arsenal. Furthermore, the sheer variety of weapon types, coupled with the Ashes of War system, provides a significant degree of customization and player expression, even without the presence of the iconic trick weapons.

Ultimately, the answer to the question of whether Elden Ring “needs” trick weapons is subjective. The lack of transformation doesn’t diminish the richness and depth of its combat system, which offers its own unique brand of challenge and tactical nuance. While the allure of transforming weapons and their impact on Bloodborne’s gameplay remain undeniable, Elden Ring stands on its own merits, offering a distinct and rewarding combat experience for players to explore and conquer.